Bucked: Why the Orioles need to fire Buck Showalter

Yes I said it, and it shouldn’t be a shock for those that have been following me on Twitter and reading my articles at Eutaw Street Report.

Seriously, it’s past time fellow Orioles fans.  There are reasons that teams fire Buck Showalter, and those reasons have been showing up far too often, especially this season and last.

I wrote for Eutaw Street Report last year about how Showalter heavily influenced the Orioles’ collapse at the end of the 2016 season culminating in their loss to the Blue Jays in the AL Wild Card game, and it seems Buck still hasn’t learned from that and is doubling down on the same type of managing.

There’s plenty of evidence to show exactly that and I’ll go into depth on each one:

1.  Hyun Soo Kim is still a benchwarmer.

If you haven’t already, I’d encourage you to read my “The Hitter vs. Slugger II” article over at Eutaw Street Report.  I would hope you would also agree there is no way that Hyun Soo Kim should have only 15 starts at this point in the season when the team is struggling to produce runs.   He’s being benched against RHPs as well as LHPs and the team is now 14-16 when he doesn’t start and 11-4 when he does.   Kim’s been on base in almost every game he’s started as well and his defense has also been superior than his competition so that can’t even be used as an excuse.

It is just asinine the way Buck Showalter has treated Hyun Soo Kim since Spring Training 2016 and I really hope Kim’s next team makes Buck look like the petty, stubborn and idiotic person that he has been in this situation.  Perhaps it might serve as a wake-up call for him and for others in terms of his supposed superior talent evaluation skills.

Kim’s treatment alone should get Showalter fired, but if you don’t think so there is more evidence to go through…

2.  The lineup construction is still poor

Adam Jones went from being the leadoff hitter in 2016 to the #2 hitter in 2017 instead of lower in the lineup.   Jones has been abysmal against LHP (47 wRC+)  as well and yet he’s still hitting 2nd when facing them.   Also as mentioned, the 18th best OBP in MLB in 2016 has been benched for a free-swinging RH hitter against RHP and when he does play, he’s batting in the bottom of the lineup.    Why Welington Castillo isn’t batting much higher vs. LHP is also a mystery as he’s been very good against them for his career (126 wRC+) and is again this season (120 wRC+).

It really doesn’t take a ton of effort to put a good lineup together and yet Buck makes the worst lineup decisions night after night and sticks with them no matter the result.  He also never tries to adjust with PHers until very late in the game if at all.  It really is maddening and it’s likely costing the Orioles precious wins early in the season.

3.  Buck is still leaving his starters in too long.

Everybody probably remembers the Wade Miley incident in Game 2 of the final series against the Yankees on October 1, 2016.  If you don’t, you are probably better off, but let’s recap those events anyway:

Buck leaves Miley in with a lead in spite of having been hit well in the 6th inning before and Miley having a pitch count of 108.  The best description to use is that Miley survived that inning so why bring him back out for the 7th when you have an expanded bullpen?   That decision lead to the bullpen ultimately imploding with the final nail in the coffin a 2-run double by Brett Gardner off of Oliver Drake and the Orioles lost a game they should have won.

The Jays also won that day, so that ended the Orioles chance to clinch the 1st Wild Card spot and home field advantage at OPACY where the Jays could have never hit a walk-off HR and where the Orioles had had more success against them instead of the Rogers Centre.

The Orioles have already experienced at least two games with a similar scenario in 2017.  One which I will go through below ended up in a horrific loss, but the other the Orioles managed to win in extra innings.

Anyway, it’s time to re-live the horror that was April 28th against (of course) the Yankees.

Kevin Gausman had made it through 6 innings against the Yankees. He had just gotten touched up  for 3 runs in the 6th inning and 1 in the 5th after pitching 4 shutout innings.  The Orioles got 2 more runs in the top of the 7th and still had a commanding 11-4 lead though and could have easily won.

Buck Showalter brought Gausman out for the 7th inning though and that’s when everything unraveled just like it did months before.

Gausman gave up an infield single to Austin Romine, and that seemed harmless, but then Buck decided to bring in Vidal Nuno instead of one of his other trusted bullpen arms like Givens, O’Day or Hart.

Buck also could have brought Nuno in with nobody on to start the inning and that one baserunner who seemed harmless could have been an out and then the Orioles would have only given up 3 runs instead of 4 when Ellsbury hit his HR, or perhaps Nuno would have been able to pitch a shutout inning without having to worry about any baserunners to start.   Anyway you look at it, Gausman should have never started that inning just like Miley never should have started the 7th inning of Game 2.  But he did, and Nuno had to pitch with a runner on and it didn’t go well.

Nuno got the first out, but then gave up a double to Chase Headley and walked Matt Holliday and then Jacoby Ellsbury with one swing made it an 11-8 game.

Givens came in and was able to get the Orioles out of the inning but the damage had been done as the Yankees had new life with Ellsbury’s grand slam.

Showalter summoned Brad Brach in the bottom of the 9th to close the game out, but Brach had just pitched 2 innings a couple of days ago, so he wasn’t exactly fresh.  Brach walked the first batter and then gave up a single to Matt Holliday to bring the tying run up in Ellsbury.  Luckily for the Orioles, Ellsbury grounded to SS but a run scored and now one swing could tie the game.  Wouldn’t you know it but the very next batter did – with Starlin Castro hitting a 2-run HR.  The game was tied but Brach was able to get the final two outs and avoid a walk-off for that inning.  In the 10th inning however, Buck turned to Jason Aquino who walked the first two batters, struck out the second and finally gave up the walk-off 3-run HR to Matt Holliday. The epic collapse was complete, and you can argue the team hasn’t been the same since.

A Wild Card berth and home-field advantage wasn’t on the line this time but the script and result was all too familiar.

4.  The regression of Manny Machado

The regression of Manny Machado has certainly been frustrating to watch.  In 2015 it seemed he’d finally turned a corner, and then in 2016 and especially 2017 he’s swinging for the fences and now making too many mental mistakes in the field.

At least he’s not swinging his fists, but whatever motivation he had from the Boston series that fueled him is gone now.  Now he looks disinterested at times and is acting like a player who already has the $400 million contract.  At least A-Rod showed up most nights.  Why has Buck allowed this to continue?  Sure he benched him one game with a “finger” issue, but why not send a clearer message?

Manny is supposed to be a leader, but the only place he is leading the Orioles is straight to mediocrity or worse.

5.  Not managing the bullpen to win every game.

Buck has shelved relievers for days on end and instead tried to win games with the likes of AAAA pitchers like Tyler Wilson and Vidal Nuno,   At some point, you can’t keep going to the AAA well and expecting the next guy up to shut out the opposition.  That’s a ton of pressure on those guys and the Orioles’ bullpen has folded under it.   Now some of it has been due to injuries, but if guys aren’t healthy, then Buck should take advantage of the 10-day  DL and get Dan Duquette to find more depth instead of trying to pitch with only 3 or 4 relievers for multiple days.

6.  Using only 3 players from an expanded 5 player bench

This is probably the most damaging offense so far because in theory this was a great idea to start the season to take advantage of the lack of a need of a 5th starter.   Buck could match up hitters with pitchers in the later innings and have some speed off the bench.  The only problem was that the only hitters he used as replacements were Rickard and Gentry during a game and most of the time it was to pinch run or act as a defensive replacement while Hyun Soo Kim and Ryan Flaherty rotted on the bench most nights.  Rickard and Gentry were also hardly ever pinch hit for when they faced tough RH relievers at the end of a game.

The worst part about this arrangement carrying further into the season though, is Buck weakened his bullpen by only carrying 6 relievers, yet he still didn’t take the advantage of having that ability to match up hitting late to end tie games for example, so he didn’t have to use them in extra innings.   Instead, while Kim and others rotted on the bench, Buck burned out his best relievers night after night in extra innings and used the Norfolk to Baltimore option shuttle to rotate in the freshest AAA pitcher to try to eat innings which hasn’t worked out well at all.  Now the Orioles are stuck with a bunch of burned out relievers when their starters can’t go the distance instead of the more fresher bunch they had in 2016.

That’s very reminiscent of the managing style of Dave Trembley who had 3 no-hit shortstops rotating on his bench and 13 pitchers for months and only used 12 of the 13.  I think we all know that Trembley’s managing is not an example to emulate.

7.  He’s more Hargrove than Weaver.

Buck also gets a lot of Earl Weaver comparisons, but he has nowhere near the emotion that Weaver showed in games.  Weaver got ejected 98 times in his career, an American League record and was never afraid to show up an umpire when he felt the team was getting screwed over.  Buck has only been ejected 14 times in his Orioles tenure.   Sure he’ll have animated conversations, but he is a little too respectful of the umpires that make terrible calls against his team, and there have been many as of late since the MASN dispute.

Mike Hargrove had a similar temperament but he got ejected 13 times in his 4 seasons with the Orioles so Buck is actually cooler tempered than Grover which is hard to imagine.

An ejection doesn’t seem like it does much, but it shows the players that you have their back and in spite of all the terrible calls and player ejections, Buck only had one ejection himself in 2016.

So that’s 7 current reasons to fire him.  Let’s look at a few more that transcend only the Orioles:

8.  Lack of postseason success

Showalter has a career 9-14 managerial record in the postseason. The 2014 ALCS was the furthest he’d taken any team and in the roughly 7.5  seasons that Showalter has managed,  the Orioles still don’t have a World Series appearance and don’t look to have one anytime soon.  Competitive baseball should no longer be the bar for a team that’s reached the postseason 3 times in that tenure, and that’s all Buck can seem to deliver.

On the other hand, teams that have fired him have almost immediately tasted success after with the Yankees and Diamondbacks winning their championships the season following his firing.  With the right moves, the Orioles could easily follow the same script IMO.

9.  Mancrushes and doghouses

Buck’s mancrushes are well known, and he seems to have an undying loyalty to those he has that mancrush on.  Buck has gone to bat for both players and coaches in his career, and it’s gotten him fired everywhere but in Baltimore.

He was first fired after a second place finish with the Yankees in 1995 in part when he refused to fire two of his coaches, Rick Down and Brian Butterfield.

David Lough, Delmon Young, Joey Rickard and Craig Gentry are a few players that stick out as being Showalter favorites as players in spite of their performance as regulars.  One should note that Buck usually comes to his senses as these players eventually became role players, but not until a few months into the season when wins have likely been sacrificed.

Buck’s doghouses though are another tale, and  many players have found their way into them over the years.   Also once they do, it is almost impossible to get out.

Alex Rodriguez is probably the most famous case as Buck wanted him gone so the Rangers dumped him for Alfonso Soriano who Buck also clashed with as he moved Soriano from his customary leadoff spot and then when that failed, he was traded to the Nationals for a package with Brad Wilkerson as the main return.   Kevin Mench is  another Rangers player who was there in 2006 and also eventually was traded to the Brewers in a blockbuster deal for Carlos Lee and Nelson Cruz.    Steve Pearce was in there early in 2014 until an injury to Chris Davis forced Buck to play Pearce at 1B but only after he was DFA’d, waived and re-signed with the team.

Henry Urrutia, who was just released by the Orioles, only got a short cup of coffee in 2013 in spite of hitting well at stops in Bowie and Norfolk .   Buck started him for about two weeks at the end of July before relegating him to PH duty only in the beginning of August and then sending him back to Norfolk and only getting him in 3 games after calling him back up in September.  He was originally a find of longtime scout Fred Ferreira, who had previously found talent like Vlad Guerrero and Bernie Williams so there was some excitement about Urrutia’s potential.   However,  Buck didn’t seem to like his defense nor the fact that he only seemed to hit opposite field singles instead of showing the power that was touted when he was signed.   Urrutia was sent to the minors again in 2014, was injured and only got one more call up in 2015 before being banished for good until his release this year.

Now of course the most recent case is Hyun Soo Kim, and who knows what his situation will be?  Will he get traded or released as well before the season ends?

Unless there is an injury, it’s a good bet seeing as Buck has been able to get rid of just about every player he hasn’t liked.  Considering Kim is one of the best professional hitters on the team, that would be a huge mistake.

10.  Teams “outgrow” him

This was the take when he was fired by the Rangers and Diamondbacks before that.  Well the Orioles are certainly a veteran team and Buck’s message doesn’t seem to be resonating any more given the sloppy play and mental mistakes.

Buck was the perfect fit for the Diamondbacks’ as the manager of an expansion team, and went from having one of the worst records in baseball (65-97) in 1998 to one of the best (100-62) in 1999.  However, that record slipped to 85-77 in 2000 as Showalter now was overseeing a team of veterans like Luis Gonzalez, Steve Finley and Randy Johnson instead of 20-somethings.  Buck was fired after 2000 and the Diamondbacks went on to win the World Series in 2001.

Buck took over the Rangers in 2003 with young talent like Alex Rodriguez, Mark Teixeira, Kevin Mench and Hank Blalock.  He took the team from 71-91 in 2003 to 89-73 in 2004 after famously shipping Alex Rodriguez to the Yankees for Alfonso Soriano and Joaquin Arias, but the Rangers regressed to below .500 in the last two years of his tenure before Buck was fired after the 2006 season.  It took longer than the Yankees or Diamondbacks,  but the Rangers eventually returned to the playoffs and had back to back World Series appearances in 2010 and 2011.

And with the Orioles, Showalter had an immediate impact on a young team when he took over from interim manager Juan Samuel finishing 34-23 to end 2010.  The next season the Orioles regressed back to 69-93 but at the very last game of the season they played spoiler and knocked the Red Sox out of the playoffs in a come from behind thriller.  That was a turning point as the 2012 Orioles built on that momentum and came out of nowhere to win an AL Wild Card spot with a 93-69 record, the reverse of 2011, and advance to the ALDS before losing to the Yankees.  The Orioles regressed back to an 85-77 record in 2013 before having their best record since 1997 going 96-66 and winning the AL East title and ALDS before being swept by the Royals in the ALCS.

Since then the Orioles finished a disappointing 81-81 in 2015, rebounded to a 89-73 record in 2016, but fell out of the division title down the stretch after leading the AL East for most of the season and barely claimed the 2nd AL Wild Card spot before being eliminated by Toronto in the biggest blunder of Buck Showalter’s managing career.

Seeing how this season is going with injuries and disappointing performances, the Orioles have likely already hit their high point with Buck Showalter.   They may sneak into the playoffs again, but there is no domination like there was in 2014 or magic like there was in 2012.    The bullpen is already burned out and veterans young and old seem unfocused and sloppy at the plate and on the field.

There’s simply no point in seeing what he can do the rest of the season because if we’ve seen the very best we are now are  seeing the regression just like the Arizona Diamondbacks and the Texas Rangers did.  The only difference is that Peter Angelos and most of the fans that support Buck seem content with just playing competitive baseball again instead of doing whatever it takes to take the team to the next level and end the 34-year World Series drought.

Now with that said that doesn’t take away any credit from Showalter from turning this team around after 14 losing seasons.  He had a major role in building this team’s confidence back up again so that they were no longer a doormat.  Managers don’t usually last as long as Buck has though, especially in the Angelos era, and as much as continuity is important, continuity for continuity’s sake is not a good enough reason to keep Showalter as the manager.

The goal needs to be to appear in and win the World Series.  The window is slamming shut (if it hasn’t already) after 2018 and Buck has never been able to get it done and likely won’t after looking at all the evidence against him.  So it’s time to do what all of Showalter’s other previous teams have done and move on to someone that can.

Orioles fans have waited far too long and don’t deserve to see their team get Bucked again.

Top image:  CC Image courtesy of Keith Allison on Flickr

13 thoughts on “Bucked: Why the Orioles need to fire Buck Showalter”

  1. There is no possible way I could disagree with this more. Continuity for continuity’s sake is the only reason to keep anyone. Baseball is a municipal institution, not really an athletic one. If I were Angelos, Showalter would have a job as long as he wants it, and I would advise to manage the game as if it were the 1930s – 1960s. Leave the starters in there. Plenty of teams won pleanth of championships with rotations that had 70-80 complete games.

    1. Thanks for the comments. The problem is that if Buck left his starters in, then the Orioles would probably lose more games then they are now. The pitchers the Orioles have are good for 5-6 innings and then the bullpen is supposed to take over. What really caused this mess is that Buck operated with only 6 relievers and burned his good ones out and kept yanking other ones back and forth between AAA and MLB. It also didn’t help that his expanded bench wasn’t made use of and the Orioles went into extra innings more than they possibly needed to because of guys like Hardy and Gentry hitting for themselves when the Orioles had a chance to win if Buck would have pinch hit a few times to get better batter-pitcher matchups. He certainly had the players to do it.

    2. Fire Dan Duquette….The O’s have had pitching issues for over 2 years and Duqette has done nothing to improve the situation. Buck does excellent with the cards he has been dealt.

  2. This article is absolutely ridiculous! Most of the points you “tried” to make go back to Dan Duquette not Buck. Duquette is what destroyed this team. I honestly hope this article was just a joke to bait people into commenting.

    1. No joke, but I’m curious why you think Dan Duquette has influence on how Buck sets the order of his lineup or how he uses his bench? Clearly Duquette has very little say in these matters. The only thing he can do is acquire and remove talent from the roster. It’s only up to Buck on how that talent is used.

  3. I will only say one thing because I don’t feel like having an in depth conversation on points or arguments for that matter. At least Buck has a post season record with the Orioles as a manager. No manager could say that of late before he arrived. Just saying, it’s nice to not be bottom for a change.

    1. But is that enough? It’s been 34 years since the Orioles won a World Series and this era is the closest they’ve been since the 1990s. The talent is mostly there but right now it isn’t being properly utilized and that’s on the manager. Sure the losing ended but there has to be a championship at some point to justify the tenure.

  4. Absolutely agree, FIRE Buck! Should’ve fired him last year after loss to Jays, unbelievable no excuses just dumb!!! And then this year not playing Hyun Soo Kim, don’t understand how you can’t play Kim when all he does is perform and win games, remember last year Kim carried the O’s to the post season and remarkable home run against the Jays – hello Buck what planet are you on? IDIOT!!!

  5. The concern I have is that there will be hardly anybody who will be willing to work under Peter Angelos, when Buck’s contract expires at the end of 2018 or for however long they may extend it. So I hate to say it, but until Angelos is gone (i.e. dead), there will be no meaningful changes that will be sure to help lead to an Orioles championship.

  6. The Orioles have no leadership or the talent to win in a league of overpayed players. Fire Buck, hire a manager who will at least motivate his players to be dissiblinned at the plate. The Orioles used to have one of the best farm systems in the league. This is were it starts. Now their system is a joke. The fans deserve better. Example. The signing of Chris Davis to the biggest contract in Orioles history. When they should have been signing good pitcher’s. Their highest paid pitcher is a bust.Manny doesn’t want to play for the Orioles any more. I don’t blame him.Sorry Oriole fans. The Orioles have no leadership at any level anymore.

    1. Fire Buck now, he is by far the worst manager in baseball. He makes all the wrong moves.Bases loaded he takes Kim out of the game and brings in Rickard to bat for him.This guy belongs at home watching the game. Bases loaded, no outs and again nO runs scored. 14 more strike outs.Enough is enough.

  7. Duquette is THE PROBLEM. What do we have to show for the deadline moves???…No rings, Pennants…NOTHING, not even a decent long term contract…Miller was the move at the time…Why wasn’t he or Cruz kept???…This man has raped our Farm System of solid to serviceable Major League Arms and our current rotation is in Dire Need of 3 arms…Awful…Remember this One???…We were considering Santana, Jimenez and Garza as Free Agency waned into late February, Atlanta swooped in and signed Ervin and as a Knee-jerk reaction we get UBALDO….HORRIBLE…We deserve much better…Oh and by the way…Ask Red Sux fans they’re opinion of the DISMANTLER!!!

  8. I’m a fan of Bucks, I 1st saw him when he managed the Albany Colonie Yankees (AA eastern league) He had the same MO from the very beginning turning around teams. It got him to the Yankees whom he turned around handed off to Torre and then the Yankees could win the series . Same with Arizona Buck Leaves they win the series.
    It’s time for him to leave the Orioles so we can win the series. Or at least participate and say lose to Pittsburgh again. (Kidding) rather Oriole’s beat the Phillies or say the Nats (now that’s better)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *